Saturday 27 September 2014

PM Modi's US Trip : Why NaMo Baiters are Suddenly Silent


Given the kind of humiliation the American establishment heaped on Narendra Modi while he was the Chief Minister of Gujarat, most supporters of Modi and even many opponents had assumed that he would remain cold and aloof towards Americans after becoming Prime Minister. By cancelling his US visa, the American establishment had treated him as a virtual criminal even though not even an FIR had been registered against him anywhere in India. There was genuine suprise and even disappointment among Modi fans when he took no time to accept the invitation of President Obama to be his guest and address the US Congress.

But anyone who knows Modi even cursorily would understand that Modi doesn't let his ego come in the way of pragmatic politics. For all his "desi" thinking Modi shares some essential traits with Americans - the most important being his fascination for and understanding of power - how to achieve it as well as how to deal with power wielders. He knows very well that to appear a tall leader, he must be endorsed by other tall leaders. If he was seen sulking vis a vis the unquestioned super power of the globe, his stature would be diminished. By contrast, the sight of the American establishment reaching out to him to make up for all the insults they heaped on him, raises his stature both at home and abroad. The fact that he did not have to woo the Americans, it is they who wooed him adds to his charisma.

But most important of all, with this one stroke, all the Modi's-Baiters at home and abroad are stumped. It is an open secret that the campaign to demonize Modi in particular and BJP in general was led by NGOs funded by American and European donor agencies with the full backing of their respective governments. Even the evangelical groups which portrayed Modi as a full blooded fascist, as a "mass murderer", did so in coordination with the political establishment of America and European countries. South Asian studies departments of American campuses became the hot beds for Hate-Modi campaign. The Anya Loombas and Teesta Setalvads could mobilize a whole network of Modi tormentors because the American establishment was behind that campaign. Modi understands very well that even Medha Patkar could create havoc for him and Gujarat over Narmada issue not because she had mass support in India but because she had the backing of American campuses, powerful donor agencies and evangelical groups. Whoever America decides to spotlight at once gets catapulted into international limelight. If The New York Times treats you as a star or a messiah of the downtrodden, how can The Times of India afford to ignore you? That is how Medha Patkar and Teesta Setalvad captured the media in India.

Even as an ordinary citizen, if you have an American visa in your passport, no country denies you visa, Likewise denial of US visa to Modi while he was CM led to several European countries also treating him as a persona non-grata.

With this one invitation all of Modi's tormentors have been silenced. 'Sabki bolti band'. All those who ran virulent campaigns against Modi's entry into the US, all those who worked to have even his video lecture cancelled for an American university are now subdued. There are no blackflag demonstrations greeting Modi in the US. No one is screaming at the American government for having invited him. The Indian community in the US is so charged that he is being treated as a rock star. This is perhaps the first time that a Prime Minister of a country is addressing a mass gathering in a foreign country.

Even the mighty Amartya Sen who had at one time led the campaign to have Modi's US visa cancelled, has had his lips sealed. He knows that compared to the lakhs of Indians dying to attend Modi's public meetings, his baiters cannot gather more than a 100 people for a protest demonstration, unless they rope in Islamic jehadi organizations for the purpose. And if Amartya Sen is silenced, how can a Teesta Setalvad or even Arundhati Roy indulge in histrionics?

Since Modi now has gained great legitimacy in the eyes of the American establishment which has been acting as the mai baap of human rights community in India, those who had made a lucrative profession out of running hate campaigns against him, feel orphaned. Their sources of funding may also start drying up.

Thus, Modi's ready acceptance of American Presidents' invitation has managed to defang all those who made his life hell, moved heaven and earth to nail him as the prime culprit of 2002 riots. As long as the UPA was in power, they were confident of achieving their ends through means fair or foul. Even though the Supreme Court appointed SIT cleared Modi's name, even though they did not succeed in getting one FIR registered against Modi, they tormented him through relentless defamation campaigns with the backing of their funders in the West. After the UPA lost power and Modi became PM, their hate campaign lost much of the media support. Yet, Teesta Setalvad & Shabnam Hashmi Gang did not give up their smear campaign. But now with the American government having befriended Modi, they seem as shell shocked as they were at the stunning defeat of Sonia Congress.

The sudden silence of the self appointed guardians of human rights in India reveals their true political worth and weightage. Their lung power, their political clout is all borrowed. The moment they lose foreign funding and foreign patronage, they begin to fade into insignificance. Most of the leading NGOs claiming to be defenders of human rights and minority rights are hot house growths. They have hardly any roots or support base in Indian society. Their clout is largely based on the clout of their handlers and financial backers.

Without having lifted a finger to discipline Indian NGO's who created hell for him, by accepting Obama's invitation Modi has effectively struck at their roots. Even the Indian media which had made common cause with Hate- Modi Campaign, is giving ga-go over Modi's US visit.
Finally, Modi also realizes that good relations with America will give him additional clout vis a vis Pakistan and China. That will lend strength to his efforts to put an end to boundary disputes between these two troublesome neighbours. Most important of all American help will be crucial in solving the chronic Kashmir problem.

And if Modi can solve the Kashmir problem once and for all - which he seems determined to do - who know the man the American establishment hounded and derided as Hitler Mark II, as a genocide perpetrator - may even get nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize!




16 comments :

  1. Hate NaMo campaign was a fallacy that turned futile. Foreign paid lobby had labelled every NaMo fan a 'fascist' supporter. At Last, Satyameva Jayate!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. "There was genuine suprise and even disappointment among Modi fans"
    Yes, as a Modi fan, I too was surprised and disappointed!
    "He knows very well that to appear a tall leader, he must be endorsed by other tall leaders."
    Perhaps, but I saw the live UNGA broadcast. That he was invited to UNGA and spoke there may impress his domestic constituency, but the members' chairs were more than half-empty. It was obvious that to the international diplomatic community this was another ho-hum protocol affair, and the dismissive thanks by the lady on the dais said as much so.

    ReplyDelete
  3. A Prime Minister of the country does not base his foreign policy on personal revenge. Modi ji did not react when America refused him visa and now that he is representing the entire nation, he cannot be so petty to base his foreign policy on his past events. It is your own narrow vision that sees the revengeful International politics. Mr. Modi is a real statesman and a great leader. The professors of this country should learn little more about the philosophy of life: 'They (the Americans) did at that time what they thought was right and Mr. Modi is doing what he thinks is right now for him as the representative of the Indian Nation.' Besides that, Mr. Modi is a spiritual person and he does not believe in revenge in life. Had he wanted, he could have taken revenge with the congress leaders who said to him such disgusting things during the election. That is his high level character that he does not indulge in such things.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Modi is at best an incompetent buffon who presided over the worst massacre of innocent minorities.

    At worst, he was complicit in the henious crime.

    A fringe minority of Indians may be fanbois (look at the state of Jayalalithaa fans today :-)) but the rest of the rational world is not required to stoop to your level of bhakti. We can only marvel at your gullibility or point out your outright bigotry!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lol innocent minority my foot .....muslims burnt kids n women n had to suffer hence.....thrre were riots like 1947 riots where millions died ....jinnah was responsible for that... entire world is against islamic terrorism ...n it will be uprooted.... inshaallah godwilling...india wiĺl always remain home to patriot muslims...others shud leave if they can find any place

      Delete
    2. MrKB,
      Its not modi who is responsible for Gujarat riots. Its yr muslim community. So blame yr godhra muslim community.

      U r the bafoon. First look at yr hatred filled muslim community n then talk abt hindus.

      Delete
    3. Who is innocent? The muslim make you listen Azan and preside next to your home is minirity? Hate filled idiots like you keep posting such stuff..you are no different from the vishal bharadwaj,anant kumar,amartya sen,yogendra yadav,teesta setalvad's..you most of them all are either dangerous communists or muslim appeasing congis..

      Delete
  5. Thank you for such a wonderful article based on facts. Modi proved himself beyond any of his foes imaginations.

    ReplyDelete
  6. just look at a Paid journalist who has only 1 question for the last 12 years and has become a leading journalist. You would have guessed by now. RAJDEEP CHORDESAI. THE INDIANS IN NEW YORK TAUGHT HIM A LESSON.

    ReplyDelete
  7. A stupid denial of unasked- for visa to Shri. Modi was unilaterally revoked and the ambassador has to go, meet and invite him in person for a visit to America explains a lot about this unique leader.

    ReplyDelete
  8. @Somu Nair I am glad you found the article useful. Please do forward it to your friends

    ReplyDelete
  9. @Bharati agree that speech at UN was a hum drum affair. But his over all visit to US not humdrum.

    ReplyDelete
  10. @KB Amazed to see how how much hatred your heart can hold for a man you hardly know. How much you must hate those you know! If you keep it up, it will corrode your own heart and turn it to ashes

    ReplyDelete
  11. Madhu, your reply to KB's comments is simply superb. KB is just trying to spit at the sky. May God bless him!

    ReplyDelete
  12. @subhash Agarwal Thanks for your feedback

    ReplyDelete
  13. @Vanaja vishal, I agree Modi is not into tit for tat politics but he certainly knows how to vanquish his enemies. At times it seems he is fascinated & mesmerized by those who ran Hate Modi campaign and is keen to win them over.

    ReplyDelete

Comments will be moderated only to censor profanity

Madhu Kishwar

Madhu Kishwar
इक उम्र असर होने तक… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …اک عمر اثر ہونے تک